Registrare Marchio

  • Who we are
    • Eva Troiani law firm: trademark registration and legal protection
    • The Project Registrare-Marchio.com
  • Trademark consultancy
    • The Verification of Trademark’s Requirements
    • Trademark Search: identity and similarity
    • Where to register a trademark
    • Filing a Trademark Application
    • Graphic Creation of a Trademark
    • Trademark protection: the surveillance service
  • Trademark legal assistance
    • Trademark defense from objections of the Trademark Office
    • Trademark defense from disputes
    • Trademark Opposition Proceedings
    • Trademark Assignment and Licence Agreement
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Certification
    • EUIPO Webinar 2023
    • SEE Webinar 2023
  • LANGUAGES
    • English English
    • Italiano Italiano
  • The trademark
    • What a Trademark is
    • How to Conceive a Brand
    • Types of Trademarks
    • Denominative and Figurative Trademark
    • Collective Trademark
    • Color Trademark
    • Position Mark
    • Slogan Trademark
    • New marks
    • Unregistered trademark
    • Deceptive Trademark
    • Trademark with Reputation
    • Family of trademarks: what they are
    • Invalid Trademark and Revocation
    • Trademark symbols which can be used in Italy: ™ and ®
    • Value of a brand
    • Trademark assignment
    • Trademark Licence agreements
    • Right of Priority of a Trademark
    • Validation of a trademark
    • Limitations of the Right on the Trademark
    • How to Avoid Complaints to a Trademark
    • Read more
  • Registering a trademark
    • Why to Register a Trademark
    • Who is Entitled to Register a Trademark
    • Filing and Registering a Trademark
    • Nice Classification – 11 edition 2022
    • Duration of a trademark
    • Registering a logo or Registering a brand?
    • How much it costs to register a trademark
    • Graphic changes to a registered trademark
    • Trademark Registration in Italy
    • Registering the European Union trademark
    • Registering an international trademark
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN EUROPE
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN THE MIDDLE EAST
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN ASIA
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN NORTH AMERICA
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN LATIN AMERICA
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN AFRICA
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN OCEANIA
    • read more
  • Mistakes not to be made
    • 10 errors not to do with trademark
    • Lack of distinctive character of a mark
    • Vulgarization of Trademark
    • Signs become customary cannot be registered as trademarks
  • Further considerations
    • CASE LAW AND TRADEMARK
    • DISTINCTIVE CHARACTER OF A TRADEMARK
    • CONTRACTS RELATED TO TRADEMARKS
    • TRADEMARKS AND BAD FAITH
    • COUNTERFEITS AND MISLEADING INDICATIONS
    • UNFAIR COMPETITION
    • GEOGRAPHICAL INDICATIONS
    • EUROPEAN UNION TRADEMARK
    • COPYRIGHT
  • News
    • Read posts
  • Guest corner

Home TRADEMARKS AND BAD FAITH Trademark in bad faith: abuse distributor’s position

Trademark in bad faith: abuse distributor’s position

by Redazione / Sunday, 01 April 2018 / Published in TRADEMARKS AND BAD FAITH

Article 19, paragraph 2 of the Italian Industrial Property Code provides that:

“who filed the application in bad faith cannot get a registration for a trademark”.

Trademark in bad faith: abuse of the distributor’s position

In this post we talk about:

  • Trademark in bad faith filed by a distributor: an italian case
  • Trademark in bad faith filed by a distributor in eu case-law

There are be many examples; among them, typical example of an application in bad faith is the filing of a trademark with the sole purpose of hindering a competitor on the market, as well as the trademark filing made by those who, being aware of the advertising carried out by an undertaking to launch a new brand and having had the opportunity to see the mark, file the trademark application before the undertaking.

Another case that can be included in the ban in question is given by the filing of a brand which is well known abroad but not in their own Country, usually made in order to forestall trademark holder and taking unfair advantage from such action, such as trying to get the maximum gain from the assignment of the mark.
Another typical hypothesis of filing in bad faith is when trademark registered in the name of the agent or representative of a person who is the proprietor of that trademark, without the proprietors’ authorization.

Trademark in bad faith filed by a distributor: an italian case

Let’s take into consideration the judgment of the Court of Appeal of Bologna of August 30, 2013, enrolled under number 52 of the general role of the year 2009, which upheld the judgment of the Court of First Instance which stated the invalidity of a trademark because of in bad faith according to such article.

The matter arises from the request of an Indian company to declare the invalidity of an Italian Trademark registration (hereinafter, trademark “XY”) filed by an Italian company, as filed in bad faith.

The Indian company, active in the field of manufacturing and marketing of polyester films, used for many years in India trademark “XY”. The product line distinguished by such mark had been distributed in Europe by the Italian company for over ten years. After the interruption of the business relationship between the two companies, the Italian company filed in its name the Italian trademark application XY. The Indian company took legal action in order to obtain the nullity of the Italian trademark registration “XY” on the assumption that Italian company filed such mark in bad faith and abused of the information acquired during their long business relationship.

The action filed by the Indian company was accepted both in the first than in the second instance.
The bad faith has been verified considering many reasons, including:

  • The Italian company was a distributor of the product XY in Europe for many years and commercialized such product in Italy. In this regard, the Court of Bologna states that

“the fact that the Italian company entered for many years the product XY in the Italian market makes us sure of its bad faith when applying for trademark registration in its own name…because in this way the Italian company was fully aware to damage the Indian company, which used the mark in Italy, bringing the usual consumers, who knew the product, to believe that another company was entitled to use the mark. This was particularly serious for the abuse of their previous relationship, including the knowledge of Italian costumers of the Indian company”;

  • There was a significant business relationship between the two companies and it is not important that such relationship was not formalized in a distribution or agent agreement.

The Court of Appeal of Bologna, therefore, confirmed the judgment of the Court of First Instance and found that

“this is, without uncertainty, a case of trademark registration in bad faith according to the Article 19, second paragraph of the Italian Industrial Property Code”.

Trademark in bad faith filed by a distributor in eu case-law

There are three cases ruled by EU Regulation 2017/1001:

  • “prohibition of the use of an EU trademark registered in the name of an agent or representative” (article 13)
    “Where an EU trademark is registered in the name of the agent or representative of a person who is the proprietor of that mark, without the proprietor’s authorization, the latter shall be entitled to oppose the use of his mark by his agent or representative if he has not authorized such use, unless the agent of representative justifies his action”
  • “Transfer of a trademark registered in the name of an agent” (article 21)
    “Where an EU trademark is registered in the name of the agent or representative of a person who is the proprietor of that trademark, without the proprietor’s authorization, the latter shall be entitled to demand the assignment of the EU trademark in his favour unless such agent or representative justifies his action”

The EU Regulation provides the following possibility for the trademark owner:

  • “Relative grounds for refusal” (article 8, paragraph 3)
    “Upon opposition by the proprietor of the trademark, a trademark shall not be registered where an agent or representative of the proprietor of the trademark applies for registration thereof in his own name without the proprietor’s consent, unless the agent or representative justifies his action”

It is important to highlight that, according to the EUIPO Trademark Practive Guidelines (part C, section 3: unauthorized filing by agents of the trademark proprietor) “the terms agent and representative should be interpreted broadly to cover all kinds of relationships based on any business arrangement (governed by written or oral contract) where one party is representing the interests of another, regardless the nomen juris of the contractual relationship between the principal-proprietor and the EUTM applicant”.


Did you find this article interesting? Share it!

They may also be interested in these items

Trademark in bad faith

Trademark protection: the surveillance service for the protection of your brand

Trademark in bad faith for violation of the principles of honesty and fairness

Eva Troiani

Eva Troiani (Attorney At Law)

Eva Troiani has been working for over 15 years dealing with all aspects of the trademark: from trademark application to trademark registration worldwide, providing assistance in the event of disputes; she proposes an extensive legal advice to companies and professionals. She is the author of all the articles in this website “registrar-marchio.com”, a project created with the aim of providing useful and updated information on the trademark’s world to all readers. You can follow the lawyer Eva Troiani also on her Linkedin profile.


 

Eva Troiani

Do you need assistance, advice or information? If you have an idea, do not let it steal!

Contact Eva Troiani’s law firm

For registration and protection of trademarks

The texts in this database are only for informational and scientific purposes and they are not to be considered official; we therefore decline any responsibility for possible errors or inaccuracies. All mentioned trademarks belong to their legitimate owners; trademarks, product names, trade names and the images of the products are the property of their respective owners. They are used in this database only for informational purposes, without any purpose of violating existing rights of others.
The information you obtained at this site is not, nor is intended to be, legal advice. You should consult Ms. Eva Troiani and/or a trademark attorney and/or an attorney at law handling with intellectual property for individual advice regarding any legal questions that you may have.

Find out why Mario decided to register his trademark

Register now your trademark!
Guest Corner

Last articles

  • Registrare un marchio in India (Trademark)

    Trademark Filings in India – Your Roadmap to Protection and Success!

    Colleague Ankita Malik explains in detail the t...
  • Tutela della voce nella giurisprudenza americana ai tempi dell'AI / voice protection in American jurisprudence

    Hey, that’s my voice! Can I sue them?

    My colleague Teresa Segalman explains what Amer...
  • Trade marks in Vietnam: “I want to overcome the refusal”!

    My colleague Nguyen Ngoc Thanh explains in deta...
  • Provisional Refusal in Japan-Rifiiuto provvisorio in Giappone

    Frequent Provisional Refusal in Japan

    A frequent ground for refusal refers to the mai...
  • Lack of distinctive character of a mark

    Lack of distinctive character of a mark

    : It is defined distinctive the sign able to id...

Category

  • THE TRADEMARK
  • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN EUROPE
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN THE MIDDLE EAST
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN ASIA
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN NORTH AMERICA
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN LATIN AMERICA
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN OCEANIA
    • REGISTERING A TRADEMARK IN AFRICA
  • MISTAKES NOT TO BE MADE WITH TRADEMARKS
  • INSIGHTS INTO BRAND
    • CASE LAW AND TRADEMARK
    • DISTINCTIVE CHARACTER OF A TRADEMARK
    • COPYRIGHT
    • CONTRACTS RELATED TO TRADEMARKS
    • TRADEMARKS AND BAD FAITH
    • COUNTERFEITS AND MISLEADING INDICATIONS
    • UNFAIR COMPETITION
    • GEOGRAPHICAL INDICATIONS
    • EUROPEAN UNION TRADEMARK

Subscribe to the newsletter

come contattare l’Avv. Eva Troiani

+393382938021

Utility

  • Eva Troiani law firm: trademark registration and legal protection
  • The Project Registrare-Marchio.com
  • Where to register a trademark
  • The Verification of Trademark’s Requirements
  • Trademark Search: identity and similarity
  • Filing a Trademark Application
  • Graphic Creation of a Trademark
  • Trademark protection: the surveillance service for the protection of your brand
  • Trademark Opposition Proceedings
  • Trademark Assignment and Licence Agreement

Contact

Eva Troiani (Attorney At Law)

P. Iva IT07106461002
+39.338.29.38.021
info@marchiebrevettiroma.it
  • Who we are
    • Eva Troiani law firm: trademark registration and legal protection
    • The Project Registrare-Marchio.com
  • Trademark consultancy
    • The Verification of Trademark’s Requirements
    • Trademark Search: identity and similarity
    • Where to register a trademark
    • Filing a Trademark Application
    • Graphic Creation of a Trademark
    • Trademark protection: the surveillance service
  • Trademark legal assistance
    • Trademark defense from objections of the Trademark Office
    • Trademark defense from disputes
    • Trademark Opposition Proceedings
    • Trademark Assignment and Licence Agreement
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Certification
    • EUIPO Webinar 2023
    • SEE Webinar 2023
  • GET SOCIAL
Registrare Marchio

registrare-marchio.com | Avv. Eva Troiani © 2015 - All rights reserved | Cookie policy | Privacy policy
The contents of this site provide readers with general information and are not legal advice.
Powered by
Ip Coster

TOP

Questo sito fa uso di cookie tecnici per permettere una corretta navigazione agli utenti e cookie di terze parti (come Google Analytics, Maps, ReCapcha, etc..) per migliorarne la fruizione. Se vuoi saperne di più consulta la nostra Cookie Policy.

Questo sito utilizza i cookie per fornire la migliore esperienza di navigazione possibile. Continuando a utilizzare questo sito senza modificare le impostazioni dei cookie o cliccando su "Accetta" permetti il loro utilizzo.

Chiudi